Mobile access is probably the largest emerging trend in the security marketplace, but it is only one of several that are changing the face of the access control market. Another factor showing potential to change the market is the emergence of location systems and positioning systems, as reflected by HID Global’s recent acquisition of Bluvision, a provider of real-time location tracking system for assets and employees, and building information modeling (BIM) is impacting how consultants do their jobs. We gathered together several consultants, and a representative of HID Global, to discuss these topics.

Participants were Chris Grniet of Guidepost Solutions, Brandon Frazier of Elert & Associates, Terry Harless of Burns & McDonnell, and Harm Radstaak, HID Global’s Vice President and Managing Director, Physical Access Control.

Future Of Mobile Access Technology

SourceSecurity.com: How is mobility affecting end-user implementations and the way you consult? How has Mobile Access technology affected the way you approach projects? 

Chris Grniet: I don’t think I am designing a single project now where we are not using a mobile credential. But the industry has been transitioning slowly to frictionless access. We looked at it 20 to 30 years ago, when we started looking at asset tracking with RFID and antennas around doors, and all of that. We are starting to see new products emerge from HID and others for personnel tracking. I think our society has progressed, and we understand that the electronic component of our lives is attached to us – not embedded yet, but attached. Everybody has that electronic device, and it’s making it a lot easier. We have implemented products for mobile credentialing for large corporations. We are really looking forward to the visitor management component of that. It will make visitor management so much easier. We need to keep it affordable. But it’s going to be there. I am designing projects now with 20 to 30 turnstile entrances to a headquarters building. We are putting in visitor management kiosks. I don’t want a single visitor to have to use those at the end of the day. I want to push the credentials out. Unless they weren’t registered, they should be able to walk through the door because they are a trusted individual. We’re moving toward frictionless access, and that’s a big component of it.  

Terry Harless: Personally, I haven’t had any projects that use any mobile applications as of yet. I have tried to design them on a couple of projects as an alternate, mainly at tech-heavy firms where they understand technology. For the most part, it has always been value-engineered out because of the price, and also because some of these are smaller companies. Some of the mobile applications have larger license packs, for a hundred or more licenses. That’s my experience.

"I think we have yet to see the advantages; people are still imagining what the full potential is of location services"

Brandon Frazier: One of my biggest verticals is higher education. I really see mobile credentials being big in that space. I see students, and they have their phones and a little holder in the back for credit cards, and that’s it. That’s all they have. I think the idea of carrying another student ID won’t fit in the phone. I really see very specific verticals having great benefits from mobile. In terms of master planning, I have seen the cost of entry as being very expensive: the cost of replacing readers, the cost of replacing downstream devices. But if I’m doing large projects, I am always spec’ing in at least the mobile infrastructure, so they can add the credentials later. 

Harm Radstaak: It’s fair to say we have learned a lot as HID in the mobile access space. As a supplier, our operational model behind the scenes has completely shifted from producing a card, encoding a card, shipping a card. Now we are issuing over the air, revoking over the air. Our IT infrastructure and the way we serve end users though our IT infrastructure has had substantial investments. Moving into the mobile access space, the requirements are higher. Is it residing in the cloud? How are we going about compliancy, privacy, security? More important, if it’s residing on your phone, questions are being asked by end users. How trusted is this? All these areas are important for HID. That’s on the operational model. The other challenge we have is the variety of phones across the world. There are development challenges to support a substantial portion of the phones worldwide, and all the diverse operating systems.

Challenges And Benefits Of Location Services

SourceSecurity.com: What are your thoughts on location services / indoor positioning services?

Grniet: Indoor positioning services should be integrated into a security platform that is pre-existing in an environment or will be deployed in an environment. There are plenty of location type services out there, whether in hospitals or factories. The signals have to be right, what we’re using as a tracking device has to be right, etc. I see some of the legacy systems laying to waste because it’s an extra set of management tools. So you need integration into the pre-existing or future systems to be deployed. We need to get everything fully integrated in a unified fashion, so we are operating on a single platform without an extraneous management platform. I think we have yet to see the advantages; people are still imagining what the full potential is of location services. It’s going to play into facility usage, area usage, safety, security, mustering; all of those things are going to be very important.

Frazier: I see a lot of potential in specific verticals and employee groups. Let’s use guards as an example: The real-time ability to locate a guard, associate that with nearby assets, using analytics, tying data together, aggregating it, putting that to a body and being able to provide a faster response time. I see that coming, but I think the cost of entry will be too high. I used to do a lot of work in healthcare as well, and the cost of entry is extremely high in tracking services. So we need to find a better way to do it. GPS is great; I don’t know if you can get that in buildings. Adding sensors every 20 feet, triangulation, it’s just not the best solution.

Grniet: With GPS we still have the height issue, especially in tall commercial buildings. So I can tell where you are on the X and Y coordinates, but not on the Z axis. That’s a big challenge. So having that built into a facility, then we can talk about asset security and asset tracking. That will be the fundamental component of how we sell it to the security side of the business.

Radstaak: I think it’s fair to say HID is very excited about location services. It’s one reason we went out to acquire a company like Bluvision. It’s not GPS, but Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE)-enabled location services. This ties into a couple of things we discussed before. You can look at it from a space utilization perspective or workplace optimization, or sustainability, for cost savings in a large corporation. We have had discussions in the pre-acquisition phase about how it would fit with our portfolio and our offerings. HID can provide additional physical and security services. For us, it’s a natural extension.

Harless: My experience is in the correctional field, where we have been using [indoor positioning] for 10 to 15 years, either for officer safety or tracking inmates. It hasn’t necessarily been very accurate. You know when a guy walks into a room because you have a detector above the door. The more expensive ones were triangulated, but they were very pricey and unaffordable unless you had some sort of funding. It has been around, and I am glad they are working it into some of the commercial spaces now. It could be very useful.

The industry has been transitioning slowly to frictionless access
Indoor positioning services should be integrated into a security platform that is pre-existing in an environment or will be deployed in an environment

BIM Applications And Trends

SourceSecurity.com: What are your thoughts on building information modeling (BIM) processes and how important are they for consultants?

Radstaak: As a supplier, we see it as an increasing request and requirement in the consultant space – some regions lead more than others. In the United Kingdom, all critical mass infrastructure projects have to be specified based on the BIM model. So HID and Assa Abloy have invested quite substantially over the last few years in making our products compatible with BIM modeling. We support it with tools such as Assa Abloy Openings Studio. As a supplier, we see it as an important trend and a way we can support the consultant market. 

Harless: For a consultant, it helps tremendously in a couple of ways. First of all, we can pull our building materials straight out of the model. Another thing is, a lot of architects and owners like to walk through buildings and look what’s on the ceilings, on the walls. When you are showing them where the cameras and card readers are going to be (in a BIM model), it’ll give the architects a good idea of what they are going to see when the building actually gets built. They can tell us where to move stuff. 

Grniet: To that end, the inception of BIM wasn’t about 3D modeling in CAD, it was about tracking of assets, and understanding everything that was on the ground. It has taken us into: Where are the intersections on construction, so we don’t have pipes running where ducts should be, and is my security equipment going where glass is? If you couldn’t read the plans, we have a BIM model to show you. You talk about seeing what a building will be like, but clients have a hard time envisioning that, seeing beyond the paper, because they are focused on another business – that’s not what they do. So we are utilizing some of the tools being provided out there by firms like HID to put the toolkit for BIM modeling in there. We’re also using it for camera focusing. It helps me get a better idea of what I’m going to see in my final product and then show the client. This is why we are focusing a camera in this area. It goes back to sustainability, asset tracking, maintenance, all those things we have talked about under other product categories. 

"The future will be security of your software, security of your credentials and your card readers"

Frazier:  When BIM is properly implemented, it has made our workflow very efficient. We have found it has been very helpful in our personal design, as Chris said. When we are trying to model a camera, we can see the space. But as a project team architect, if it is not properly implemented or misunderstood, it has created a lot of extraneous tasks for us. And has made us very inefficient. Some people are very good at it, and the process goes really well. Other times we find people concentrate too much on collisions and it doesn’t end up like that in the field, or we design it one way and it ends up another way. It’s very helpful to us in our personal design, but as a project team, it can cause difficulties.  

Grniet: Just to add on to that point: We are still having trouble making the companies that manufacture BIM systems understand security’s role in the overall process. It’s easy for an architect to say I have strikes and hardware sets in my BIM model, but it’s under the architectural model. Security lies in this middle ground. We’re electronics, we’re low-voltage. The intersections, the toolkits, everybody’s got a great Revit model of their product, but it’s not in any of the toolkits. We have to build our own. The industry as a whole has a challenge to find the right place to be. Some people are using the MEP (mechanical, engineering and plumbing) model for Revit, some people are using the architectural model. But we have to build our own toolkits, so it’s still a challenge. 

Harless: At Burns and McDonnell we have it a little easier because we work with our internal architects. So we do have those tools actually built in-house. When we go to an outside or a third-party architect, to MEP firms, we have the same issues. Sometimes they will delete ceilings or walls instead of moving them, and then we have stuff all over the place.

Future Trends For Physical Access And Identity Technology

SourceSecurity.com: What do you think the identity technology industry as a whole should pay attention to over the next one to three years?  What is your vision for the future in physical access or the office space of the future?

Grniet: It’s about convergence of multiple areas of business, security of that convergence, the identification and the operability, and unified platforms to allow single vision, reduced resources and fully effective control and management of security, life safety, building management, you name it.

Frazier: To sum it up: Cybersecurity and unification will drive migration basically. We need a more cybersecure solution, which will drive migration to other solutions, and that’s when conversations about global, logical security, what else can I do with this? Single sign-on. The big picture will drive a lot of this.

Radstaak: The consolidation of technology from different industries will be substantial. It could come from the IT infrastructure, it might come from identity providers who are not currently operating in the security space. I think we currently don’t see yet the substance and the impact of the data analytics and how we can use that in security and broader applications. The services component will be substantial.

Harless: The future will be security of your software, security of your credentials and your card readers. And integration, integration, integration.

Grniet: And let’s not forget frictionless access.

Read part 3 of our Consultants' Forum series here

Read part 3 of our Consultants' Forum series here

Share with LinkedIn Share with Twitter Share with Facebook Share with Facebook
Download PDF version Download PDF version

Author profile

Larry Anderson Editor, SecurityInformed.com & SourceSecurity.com

An experienced journalist and long-time presence in the US security industry, Larry is SecurityInformed.com's eyes and ears in the fast-changing security marketplace, attending industry and corporate events, interviewing security leaders and contributing original editorial content to the site. He leads SecurityInformed's team of dedicated editorial and content professionals, guiding the "editorial roadmap" to ensure the site provides the most relevant content for security professionals.

In case you missed it

How Have Security Solutions Failed Our Schools?
How Have Security Solutions Failed Our Schools?

School shootings are a high-profile reminder of the need for the highest levels of security at our schools and education facilities. Increasingly, a remedy to boost the security at schools is to use more technology. However, no technology is a panacea, and ongoing violence and other threats at our schools suggest some level of failure. We asked this week’s Expert Panel Roundtable: How have security solutions failed our schools and what is the solution?

Why Visualization Platforms Are Vital For An Effective Security Operation Center (SOC)
Why Visualization Platforms Are Vital For An Effective Security Operation Center (SOC)

Display solutions play a key role in SOCs in providing the screens needed for individuals and teams to visualize and share the multiple data sources needed in an SOC today. Security Operation Center (SOC) Every SOC has multiple sources and inputs, both physical and virtual, all of which provide numerous data points to operators, in order to provide the highest levels of physical and cyber security, including surveillance camera feeds, access control and alarm systems for physical security, as well as dashboards and web apps for cyber security applications. Today’s advancements in technology and computing power not only have increasingly made security systems much more scalable, by adding hundreds, if not thousands, of more data points to an SOC, but the rate at which the data comes in has significantly increased as well. Accurate monitoring and surveillance This has made monitoring and surveillance much more accurate and effective, but also more challenging for operators, as they can’t realistically monitor the hundreds, even thousands of cameras, dashboards, calls, etc. in a reactive manner. Lacking situational awareness is often one of the primary factors in poor decision making In order for operators in SOC’s to be able to mitigate incidents in a less reactive way and take meaningful action, streamlined actionable data is needed. This is what will ensure operators in SOC truly have situational awareness. Situational awareness is a key foundation of effective decision making. In its simplest form, ‘It is knowing what is going on’. Lacking situational awareness is often one of the primary factors in poor decision making and in accidents attributed to human error. Achieving ‘true’ situational awareness Situational awareness isn’t just what has already happened, but what is likely to happen next and to achieve ‘true’ situational awareness, a combination of actionable data and the ability to deliver that information or data to the right people, at the right time. This is where visualization platforms (known as visual networking platforms) that provide both the situational real estate, as well as support for computer vision and AI, can help SOCs achieve true situational awareness Role of computer vision and AI technologies Proactive situational awareness is when the data coming into the SOC is analyzed in real time and then, brought forward to operators who are decision makers and key stakeholders in near real time for actionable visualization. Computer vision is a field of Artificial Intelligence that trains computers to interpret and understand digital images and videos. It is a way to automate tasks that the human visual system can also carry out, the automatic extraction, analysis and understanding of useful information from a single image or a sequence of images. There are numerous potential value adds that computer vision can provide to operation centers of different kinds. Here are some examples: Face Recognition: Face detection algorithms can be applied to filter and identify an individual. Biometric Systems: AI can be applied to biometric descriptions such as fingerprint, iris, and face matching. Surveillance: Computer vision supports IoT cameras used to monitor activities and movements of just about any kind that might be related to security and safety, whether that's on the job safety or physical security. Smart Cities: AI and computer vision can be used to improve mobility through quantitative, objective and automated management of resource use (car parks, roads, public squares, etc.) based on the analysis of CCTV data. Event Recognition: Improve the visualization and the decision-making process of human operators or existing video surveillance solutions, by integrating real-time video data analysis algorithms to understand the content of the filmed scene and to extract the relevant information from it. Monitoring: Responding to specific tasks in terms of continuous monitoring and surveillance in many different application frameworks: improved management of logistics in storage warehouses, counting of people during event gatherings, monitoring of subway stations, coastal areas, etc. Computer Vision applications When considering a Computer Vision application, it’s important to ensure that the rest of the infrastructure in the Operation Center, for example the solution that drives the displays and video walls, will connect and work well with the computer vision application. The best way to do this of course is to use a software-driven approach to displaying information and data, rather than a traditional AV hardware approach, which may present incompatibilities. Software-defined and open technology solutions Software-defined and open technology solutions provide a wider support for any type of application the SOC may need Software-defined and open technology solutions provide a wider support for any type of application the SOC may need, including computer vision. In the modern world, with everything going digital, all security services and applications have become networked, and as such, they belong to IT. AV applications and services have increasingly become an integral part of an organization’s IT infrastructure. Software-defined approach to AV IT teams responsible for data protection are more in favor of a software-defined approach to AV that allow virtualised, open technologies as opposed to traditional hardware-based solutions. Software’s flexibility allows for more efficient refreshment cycles, expansions and upgrades. The rise of AV-over-IP technologies have enabled IT teams in SOC’s to effectively integrate AV solutions into their existing stack, greatly reducing overhead costs, when it comes to technology investments, staff training, maintenance, and even physical infrastructure. AV-over-IP software platforms Moreover, with AV-over-IP, software-defined AV platforms, IT teams can more easily integrate AI and Computer Vision applications within the SOC, and have better control of the data coming in, while achieving true situational awareness. Situational awareness is all about actionable data delivered to the right people, at the right time, in order to address security incidents and challenges. Situational awareness is all about actionable data delivered to the right people Often, the people who need to know about security risks or breaches are not physically present in the operation centers, so having the data and information locked up within the four walls of the SOC does not provide true situational awareness. hyper-scalable visual platforms Instead there is a need to be able to deliver the video stream, the dashboard of the data and information to any screen anywhere, at any time — including desktops, tablets phones — for the right people to see, whether that is an executive in a different office or working from home, or security guards walking the halls or streets. New technologies are continuing to extend the reach and the benefits of security operation centers. However, interoperability plays a key role in bringing together AI, machine learning and computer vision technologies, in order to ensure data is turned into actionable data, which is delivered to the right people to provide ‘true’ situational awareness. Software-defined, AV-over-IP platforms are the perfect medium to facilitate this for any organizations with physical and cyber security needs.

Securing Mobile Vehicles: The Cloud and Solving Transportation Industry Challenges
Securing Mobile Vehicles: The Cloud and Solving Transportation Industry Challenges

Securing Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS) in the transportation industry is multi-faceted for a multitude of reasons. Pressures build for transit industry players to modernise their security systems, while also mitigating the vulnerabilities, risks, and growth-restrictions associated with proprietary as well as integrated solutions. There are the usual physical security obstacles when it comes to increasingly integrated solutions and retrofitting updated technologies into legacy systems. Starting with edge devices like cameras and intelligent sensors acquiring video, analytics and beyond, these edge devices are now found in almost all public transportation like buses, trains, subways, airplanes, cruise lines, and so much more. You can even find them in the world’s last manually operated cable car systems in San Francisco. The next layer to consider is the infrastructure and networks that support these edge devices and connect them to centralized monitoring stations or a VMS. Without this layer, all efforts at the edge or stations are in vain as you lose the connection between the two. And the final layer to consider when building a comprehensive transit solution is the software, recording devices, or viewing stations themselves that capture and report the video. The challenge of mobility However, the transportation industry in particular has a very unique challenge that many others do not – mobility. As other industries become more connected and integrated, they don’t usually have to consider going in and out or bouncing between networks as edge devices physically move. Obviously in the nature of transportation, this is key. Have you ever had a bad experience with your cellular, broadband or Wi-Fi at your home or office? You are not alone. The transportation industry in particular has a very unique challenge that many others do not – mobility Can you trust these same environments to record your surveillance video to the Cloud without losing any frames, non-stop 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year? To add to the complexity – how do you not only provide a reliable and secure solution when it’s mobile, traveling at varying speeds, and can be in/out of coverage using various wireless technologies? Waiting to upload video from a transport vehicle when it comes into port, the station, or any centralized location is a reactive approach that simply will not do any longer. Transit operations require a more proactive approach today and the ability to constantly know what is going on at any given time on their mobile vehicles, and escalate that information to headquarters, authorities, or law enforcement if needed; which can only occur with real-time monitoring. This is the ultimate question when it comes to collecting, analyzing, and sharing data from mobile vehicles – how to get the video from public transportation vehicles alike to headquarters in real time! Managing video data In order to answer this question, let’s get back to basics. The management and nature of video data differs greatly from conventional (IT) data. Not only is video conducted of large frames, but there are specific and important relationships among the frames and the timing between them. This relationship can easily get lost in translation if not handled properly. This is why it’s critical to consider the proper way to transmit large frames while under unstable or variable networks. The Internet and its protocols were designed more than two decades ago and purposed for conventional data. Although the Internet itself has not changed, today’s network environments run a lot faster, expand to further ranges, and support a variety of different types of data. Because the internet is more reliable and affordable than in the past some might think it can handle anything. However, it is good for data, but not for video. This combination makes it the perfect time to convert video recording to the Cloud! Video transmission protocol One of the main issues with today’s technology is the degradation of video quality when transmitting video over the Internet. ITS are in dire need for reliable transmission of real-time video recording. To address this need a radical, yet proven, video transmission protocol has recently been introduced to the market. It uses AI technology and to adapt to different environments in order to always deliver high quality, complete video frames. This protocol, when equipped with encryption and authentication, enables video to be transmitted reliably and securely over the Internet in a cloud environment. One of the main issues with today’s technology is the degradation of video quality when transmitting video over the Internet Finally, transportation industry has a video recording Cloud solution that is designed for (massive) video that can handle networks that might be experiencing high error rate. Such a protocol will not only answer the current challenges of the transportation industry, but also make the previously risky Cloud environment safe for even the most reserved environments and entities. With revolutionary transmission protocols, the time is now to consider adopting private Cloud for your transportation operations.