Image quality is affected by more than just zoom
Image quality is affected by more than just zoom
Surveillance cameras are only as useful as the quality of images they produce.  Therefore when selecting cameras for a security system, it is imperative to select one with features that will provide the best results possible.  It is often thought that the higher the zoom, the better the quality of the images produced.  However, this is not always necessarily the case. Phil Doyle, Regional Director, Northern Europe at Axis Communications, explains why this is so and discusses the different factors which affect image quality.

In the world of security cameras, 18x zoom can be equal to 36x. More specifically, a high-resolution security camera with 18x optical zoom can provide images that, for surveillance purposes, are just as, or even more useful than those delivered by a standard resolution, 4CIF camera with twice the zoom capability.

Compare the pictures below. Figure 1 shows a 36x zoomed-in view using a pan/tilt/zoom (PTZ) camera with 4CIF resolution (704 x 480 pixels). Figure 3 shows an 18x zoomed-in view using an HDTV 720p PTZ camera with a resolution of 1280 x 720 pixels.
 4CIF tele-view with 36x zoom 4CIF camera with 36x zoom cropped view
Fig. 1  4CIF camera max tele-view with 36x zoom Fig. 2  Cropped view of image at left
 HDTV 720p camera with 18x zoom max. tele-view HDTV 720p camera with 18x zoom max. cropped view
Fig. 3  HDTV 720p camera with 18x zoom max. tele-view Fig. 4  Cropped view of image at left

The pixel resolution in both cases is virtually the same: the newspaper's name, for example, is readable. However, the HDTV camera offers the same details with just half the zoom capability of the standard-resolution camera.

It is also important to note that the HDTV network camera's wider (16:9) field of view makes it possible to monitor a larger area without compromising image details. In the image from the 4CIF camera (Figure 1), only one person can be seen in the picture, while in the HDTV image, the operator can see more than one person and simultaneously pick up small details such as texts on the newspaper. So while the level of detail is similar, the HDTV 720p camera enables more of a scene to be seen, which is advantageous in surveillance situations. The wider field of view in zoomed-in mode also makes tracking easier and more reliable since the risk of losing sight of a person or object while panning or tilting the camera is reduced.

How can an 18x zoom camera then produce the same level of detail as a 36x zoom camera?

It is a common assumption that the higher the zoom factor of a lens, the better its ability to magnify a scene and make details more visible. This is not always true, as illustrated above.

A zoom lens is an assembly of lenses with the ability to vary its focal length. A longer focal length means stronger magnifying power, but also a proportional reduction in the angle of view.

A lens with a higher zoom factor may not necessarily have the stronger magnification capability

The zoom capability of a lens is usually expressed as the ratio between its longest and shortest focal lengths. For example, a zoom lens with focal lengths ranging from 50 mm to 200 mm is referred to as a 4x zoom lens, or sometimes a 4:1 zoom lens. (Seen another way, using the maximum zoom on this lens will reduce the angle of view to roughly one fourth of the widest angle.) Two different lenses with the same zoom factor may therefore perform very differently since their focal lengths and magnifying power may not be the same but their ratio is. Furthermore, a lens with a higher zoom factor may not necessarily have the stronger magnification capability. For instance, a lens with a focal length that ranges from 15 mm to 150 mm-a 10x zoom lens-would actually have a weaker magnifying capability than a 4x zoom lens with focal lengths ranging from 50 mm to 200 mm since the 200 mm focal length has a stronger magnifying power than a 150 mm focal length.

See an example of the clarity of a 18x zoom security camera 
Factoring in resolution

However, like zoom factors, determining the magnification capabilities simply by the focal length number can also be misleading. The 4CIF security camera used to produce the image samples above has a longer focal length than the HDTV 720p camera. How then can the level of detail in the zoomed-in images be similar?

Let's take a look at how the cameras perform in wide mode; that is, using their smallest focal lengths (with no zoom). Compare the pictures below.
4CIF camera wide view 4CIF camera cropped view
Fig. 6  4CIF camera wide view Fig. 6  Cropped view of image at left
 HDTV 720p camera with wide view HDTV 720p camera cropped view
Fig. 7  HDTV 720p camera with wide view Fig. 8  Cropped view of image at left
The field of view in both cases is almost identical. However, the higher resolution and better color fidelity in the HDTV camera is immediately apparent, producing sharp, crisp pictures with great detail. Compare the cropped-out views of Figures 6 and 8. The numbers on the score board are visible in the HDTV image while hardly visible in the image from the 4CIF camera.

These images show that in wide mode, the HDTV network camera offers much more details than the 4CIF camera. In fact, the HDTV camera has almost double the number of pixels for the same field of view. In tele or full zoom mode, the HDTV and the 4CIF camera offer virtually the same level of detail, but the HDTV camera has a wider field of view.

Image quality is not defined by pixel resolution alone.  Other elements, such as the resolving power and quality of a lens, have an impact.



These results illustrate that comparing a security camera's magnification capability simply by looking at the zoom factor can be misleading. It is important, as this exercise demonstrates, to take into account the camera's pixel resolution. Compared with a standard 4CIF camera, an HDTV camera with 1280 x 720 pixels will have two to three times more pixels in every frame. The high pixel resolution is why an HDTV network camera can perform just as well with limited zoom. High resolution PTZ cameras, in fact, can be used in different ways: either to maintain the same field of view as 4CIF cameras and improve the level of detail seen as in the case with the HDTV camera used here, or to increase the field of view with the same level of image detail as standard cameras.

Other factors affecting image quality of security cameras

Image quality, however, is not defined by pixel resolution alone. Other elements, such as the resolving power and overall quality of a lens, as well as the properties and quality of the glass in a dome cover, have an impact. Another important factor is having full frame rate video streaming so that activities in a scene and fast-moving objects can be easily seen and captured. An HDTV network camera that is compliant with the SMPTE standards in resolution, frame rate, color fidelity and aspect ratio ensures that a rich viewing experience with excellent image detail is provided.

In conclusion, an HDTV network camera has shown that it can fulfill demanding surveillance requirements using just half the zoom, demonstrating that what appears sometimes to be less, is more.
Phil Doyle, Regional Director, Northern Europe at Axis Communications  Phil Doyle,
Regional Director,
Northern Europe
Axis Communications
Share with LinkedIn Share with Twitter Share with Facebook Share with Facebook
Download PDF version Download PDF version

In case you missed it

New Markets For AI-Powered Smart Cameras In 2021
New Markets For AI-Powered Smart Cameras In 2021

Organizations faced a number of unforeseen challenges in nearly every business sector throughout 2020 – and continuing into 2021. Until now, businesses have been on the defensive, reacting to the shifting workforce and economic conditions, however, COVID-19 proved to be a catalyst for some to accelerate their long-term technology and digitalization plans. This is now giving decision-makers the chance to take a proactive approach to mitigate current and post-pandemic risks. These long-term technology solutions can be used for today’s new world of social distancing and face mask policies and flexibly repurposed for tomorrow’s renewed focus on efficiency and business optimization. For many, this emphasis on optimization will likely be precipitated by not only the resulting economic impacts of the pandemic but also the growing sophistication and maturity of technologies such as Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning (ML), technologies that are coming of age just when they seem to be needed the most.COVID-19 proved to be a catalyst for some to accelerate their long-term technology and digitalization plans Combined with today’s cutting-edge computer vision capabilities, AI and ML have produced smart cameras that have enabled organizations to more easily implement and comply with new health and safety requirements. Smart cameras equipped with AI-enabled intelligent video analytic applications can also be used in a variety of use cases that take into account traditional security applications, as well as business or operational optimization, uses – all on a single camera. As the applications for video analytics become more and more mainstream - providing valuable insights to a variety of industries - 2021 will be a year to explore new areas of use for AI-powered cameras. Optimizing production workflows and product quality in agriculture Surveillance and monitoring technologies are offering value to industries such as agriculture by providing a cost-effective solution for monitoring of crops, business assets and optimizing production processes. As many in the agriculture sector seek to find new technologies to assist in reducing energy usage, as well as reduce the environmental strain of modern farming, they can find an unusual ally in smart surveillance. Some niche farming organizations are already implementing AI solutions to monitor crops for peak production freshness in order to reduce waste and increase product quality.  For users who face environmental threats, such as mold, parasites, or other insects, smart surveillance monitoring can assist in the early identification of these pests and notify proper personnel before damage has occurred. They can also monitor vast amounts of livestock in fields to ensure safety from predators or to identify if an animal is injured. Using video monitoring in the growing environment as well as along the supply chain can also prove valuable to large-scale agriculture production. Applications can track and manage inventory in real-time, improving knowledge of high-demand items and allowing for better supply chain planning, further reducing potential spoilage. Efficient monitoring in manufacturing and logistics New challenges have arisen in the transportation and logistics sector, with the industry experiencing global growth. While security and operational requirements are changing, smart surveillance offers an entirely new way to monitor and control the physical side of logistics, correcting problems that often go undetected by the human eye, but have a significant impact on the overall customer experience. Smart surveillance offers an entirely new way to monitor and control the physical side of logistics, correcting problems that often go undetected by the human eye. Video analytics can assist logistic service providers in successfully delivering the correct product to the right location and customer in its original condition, which normally requires the supply chain to be both secure and ultra-efficient. The latest camera technology and intelligent software algorithms can analyze footage directly on the camera – detecting a damaged package at the loading dock before it is loaded onto a truck for delivery. When shipments come in, smart cameras can also alert drivers of empty loading bays available for offloading or alert facility staff of potential blockages or hazards for incoming and outgoing vehicles that could delay delivery schedules planned down to the minute. For monitoring and detecting specific vehicles, computer vision in combination with video analysis enables security cameras to streamline access control measures with license plate recognition. Smart cameras equipped with this technology can identify incoming and outgoing trucks - ensuring that only authorized vehicles gain access to transfer points or warehouses. Enhance regulatory safety measures in industrial settings  Smart surveillance and AI-enabled applications can be used to ensure compliance with organizational or regulatory safety measures in industrial environments. Object detection apps can identify if employees are wearing proper safety gear, such as facial coverings, hard hats, or lifting belts. Similar to the prevention of break-ins and theft, cameras equipped with behavior detection can help to automatically recognize accidents at an early stage. For example, if a worker falls to the ground or is hit by a falling object, the system recognizes this as unusual behavior and reports it immediately. Going beyond employee safety is the ability to use this technology for vital preventative maintenance on machinery and structures. A camera can identify potential safety hazards, such as a loose cable causing sparks, potential wiring hazards, or even detect defects in raw materials. Other more subtle changes, such as gradual structural shifts/crack or increases in vibrations – ones that would take the human eye months or years to discover – are detectable by smart cameras trained to detect the first signs of mechanical deterioration that could potentially pose a physical safety risk to people or assets. Early recognition of fire and smoke is another use case where industrial decision-makers can find value. Conventional fire alarms are often difficult to properly mount in buildings or outdoor spaces and they require a lot of maintenance. Smart security cameras can be deployed in difficult or hard-to-reach areas. When equipped with fire detection applications, they can trigger notification far earlier than a conventional fire alarm – as well as reduce false alarms by distinguishing between smoke, fog, or other objects that trigger false alarms. By digitizing analog environments, whether a smoke detector or an analog pressure gauge, decision-makers will have access to a wealth of data for analysis that will enable them to optimize highly technical processes along different stages of manufacturing - as well as ensure employee safety and security of industrial assets and resources. Looking forward to the future of smart surveillance With the rise of automation in all three of these markets, from intelligent shelving systems in warehouses to autonomous-driving trucks, object detection for security threats, and the use of AI in monitoring agricultural crops and livestock, the overall demand for computer vision and video analytics will continue to grow. That is why now is the best time for decision-makers across a number of industries to examine their current infrastructure and determine if they are ready to make an investment in a sustainable, multi-use, and long-term security and business optimization solution.

How Technology Can Elevate Guest Services And Their Security
How Technology Can Elevate Guest Services And Their Security

The return to the workplace is a focal point for many in the built environment but one of the most important elements is easy to overlook. Guest services will be vital in the return to the workplace. Front-of-house teams will be responsible for welcoming building users back and reassuring them as they negotiate shared spaces in the post-Covid era. The workplace will inevitably look different after Covid. We have become more aware of our spaces, how clean they are, and what spaces building users share. Employees have also become more conscious of the pros and cons of the workplace. For some, a year of working from home has been a welcome break from the stress and time taken by a commute. Many organizations are considering moving to hybrid workplace approaches, downsizing their corporate real estate portfolio, and using shared spaces more consciously, be that for focussed quiet work or collaboration. We will also see heightened care in workplace cleaning and more data-led solutions. Front-of-house teams will be at the center of helping building users get used to these changes. The role of technology Front-of-house personnel will likely be responsible for ensuring buildings do not exceed safe occupancy levels and will be aided by visitor management systems.  Another change to look out for in the workplace will be the use of technology. Tech-led organizations have long reminded us that gut instinct and trusting our senses is not enough anymore, but Covid-19 has forced us to come to terms with this. Now that adopting technology has become crucial in cleaning, we will see a reticence to adopt it elsewhere fade too. A survey from McKinsey suggests that the pandemic has accelerated the adoption of technologies by several years. Why is this important for guest services? Much like other workplace changes, new technologies will alter how building users interact with their environment. Tech will also enable front-of-house teams to focus on the key ingredient of their role – human interaction. This will be vital in helping occupants feel comfortable, safe, and happy. Occupancy and visitor management systems These systems have been around in the workplace for many years, and pre-Covid were used to help us maximize our space and utilization. These systems are even more important as we are likely to see some return to the workplace before everyone has been vaccinated. We may see systems that contact only those occupants in an affected area of a building, rather than a whole workforce, to limit worry and ensure most people can remain confident in the hygiene of their workspace. For the rest of 2021 at least, precautions such as social distancing will need to be in place. Workplaces will continue to function at limited occupancy for some time to keep people safe. Front-of-house personnel will likely be responsible for ensuring buildings do not exceed safe occupancy levels and will be aided by visitor management systems. These may be used by individual organizations or by multi-tenanted buildings. Temperature checks and identity verification systems Organizations are mitigating risks where possible. Handheld digital thermometers have been in high demand. The use of such devices has reshaped the role of security officers over the past year. Officers have become familiar faces in shops and shared spaces, keeping people safe and acting as the first point of contact. The security sector has been placed under immense pressure, balancing the need to enforce precautions with responding to stressed building users in an empathetic way. Officers have demonstrated agility that security technology cannot replace. Post-pandemic, we will likely see a greater appreciation for what manned guarding can offer and a greater potential for officers in front of house roles. Front-of-House staff are becoming responsible for temperature verification. Some organizations may choose to increase the collaboration between their front-of-house and security teams. This could include implementing identity verification systems, as well as touchless systems. This will allow the focus of front-of-house teams to remain on the people and giving a warm welcome to users as they return to the office. Using monitoring to make guest services more available  Monitoring solutions may be the first things that come to mind when discussing security technology. We have seen an increasing trend toward integrating remote monitoring with manned guarding since before the pandemic. Such a move may be even more important now.Beyond keeping employees safe, guest services are going to play a central role in making the workplace an attractive option. For many organizations, the pandemic has forced a rapid switch in focus. Organizations have had to face the security challenges of caring for vacant premises and the additional complications of managing cybersecurity for remote work. Rebalancing the cost and focus of security may feel as though it has left some businesses without the capacity to utilize front-of-house officers. Yet when employees return to the workplace, front-of-house teams will be more important than ever. For those that did not do so during the pandemic, now is the time to be investing in effective monitoring solutions. The falling cost of technology means such a solution can be combined with manned guarding and front-of-house roles. Organizations may need to invest in fewer officers, but their roles can be more focused upon the occupant experience. Encouraging employees back Beyond keeping employees safe, guest services are going to play a central role in making the workplace an attractive option. Remote working has had both pros and cons but many of those downsides will be diminished with the end of the pandemic. Loneliness will no longer be such a challenge when seeing friends and neighbours is an option, and the return of children and partners to school and work will relieve distractions. It may be tempting, then, for many employees to continue working from home. As a result, many opportunities for collaborative work will be lost. For employers looking to encourage their workforce to return, creating an amazing workplace experience is key. Technology alone can’t offer this. Rather, too much tech could create an environment that feels clinical and impersonal. Use technology to streamline the boring or stressful elements of the workplace and invest in friendly faces who will welcome your workforce back.

What are the Security Challenges of Protecting the Cannabis Industry?
What are the Security Challenges of Protecting the Cannabis Industry?

The advent of a truly new market for the physical security industry is a rare occurrence. Particularly rare is a new market that is both fast-growing and provides an environment that is not just conducive to application of physical security technologies but that actually demands it. Such is the case with the market for legalized marijuana. We asked this week’s Expert Panel Roundtable: What are the security challenges of protecting the cannabis industry?