The Caisse d’Épargne banking group needed to cost-effectively extend the benefits of surveillance monitoring into 70 regional branch offices throughout France.  The new surveillance system needed to meet the banks high expectations for security, reliability, and quality.


Up to three Axis network cameras were installed directly to the existing networks within each regional bank.  Using standard frame relay protocol, the bank headquarters can access surveillance images from each regional office over a secure network.


A cost analysis of alternative surveillance systems revealed that an Axis-based network solution cost nearly 5 times less than any comparative CCTV solution.  More than 180 Axis network cameras provide real opportunity to capture detailed photographic evidence of any criminal activity from over 70 regional banks.  Staff are relinquished from the time consuming responsibility of changing and storing magnetic tapes.  Bank employees appreciate the reassurance of a modern technology that extends remote surveillance access to the bank’s headquarters and security contractors during emergency situations.


“We are extremely pleased with the results. This is really just the start of our strategic migration from analog CCTV to IP-Surveillance technology.”  Mr Guy Kleiber, Chief Technical & Information Officer Caisse d’Épargne Bank, Val de France-Orléanais.


Discovering a CCTV alternative

With many of their regional branch offices already benefiting from the use of traditional analog CCTV (closed circuit television) as a precaution against theft, armed robbery and fraud, the Caisse d’Épargne Bank investigated the extension of surveillance cameras to another 70 offices.  In examining the costs, they quickly discovered a much cheaper and sophisticated alternative—in Axis network cameras.

Employing over 44,000 staff in over 450 banks throughout the country, Caisse d’Épargne serves an estimated 26 million customers, and is the third largest depository bank in France.  Requiring the surveillance coverage of up to three strategically placed cameras within each branch office, the potential cost saving for the national rollout of cameras was considerable.

Mr. Guy Kleiber, Chief Technical and Information Officer at the Caisse d’Épargne Bank in Val de France-Orléanais, was the man initially charged with investigating the alternative surveillance solutions.  With an emphasis on security, reliability, quality, and cost-efficiency, Mr. Kleiber analyzed the comparative costs of analog CCTV against a modern IP-surveillance system.  He concluded that a network camera solution from Axis would cost between 3.5 to 4.9 times less than any comparative analog solution.

Life without tape!

Unlike analog CCTV that requires dedicated cabling for every new camera installation, IP-surveillance systems utilize existing LAN topologies for video transmission to offer a quick and uncomplicated installation.  However, it was the tangible savings associated with digital video storage - rather than convenient image transmission - that really enticed the Caisse d’Épargne Bank towards an Axis-based network solution.

CCTV is typically recorded onto large reels of degradable magnetic tape, which places huge demand on finding the physical space needed for tape archives.  Furthermore, the tape drive assemblies used for recording surveillance images to the tape employ sophisticated pneumatic drive assemblies that are all too unreliable to maintain.  The volatile nature of magnetic tape, combined with a necessity to house each tape drive within an expensive security enclosure, clearly makes analog video inappropriate for any new surveillance system.  Concerns over the general reliability of analog tape were also compounded by some obvious difficulties regional banking staff experienced when changing tapes.

“Frequently preoccupied with an abundance of customer enquiries and other daily responsibilities, staff would occasionally forget to change tapes.  This ultimately led to several security incidents not being recorded. It’s understandable, but from a security perspective, it was a clearly unacceptable situation”, explained Mr Kleiber.

Using the File Transfer Protocol (FTP), the digital images produced by Axis’ network cameras are conveniently transmitted over an IP network onto computer hard disk-without any operator intervention whatsoever.

“With Axis network cameras we needn’t worry about maintenance or storage overheads. Our staff need no longer concern themselves with tapes” said Mr Kleiber.

Image storage over the network

The imaging specification for the new cameras was defined by Direction du Patrimoine Immobilier et de la Securité – the specialist security and building management team at the bank.  In understanding that consistent image quality is vital for good object recognition, the group concluded that the new system must guarantee consistent image resolution at all times—regardless of any intermediate reductions in the network bandwidth.  With this as a prerequisite, an imaging frequency of one image every three seconds would be more than sufficient for the purposes of identification.

As AXIS 2100 Network Cameras are capable of delivering up to 10 standard JPEG images every second, meeting this comparatively modest specification was never going to be an issue”, explained Mr. Kleiber.

Apart from the operational benefits, banking staff also enjoy the reassurance of knowing that, in any emergency situation, the bank headquarters and security partners can access the surveillance images at anytime over the corporate network, using a standard frame relay protocol.  Empowered with the ability to remotely monitor the front reception desk and keep a check on customer waiting queues – without leaving their offices – the regional bank managers are also very pleased with the new Axis system.

With digital images that can be posted into e-mail and many other security applications over the network, potential raiders can now rely on the bank’s efficiency in providing timely photographic evidence of their activities to local police authorities.

Just the beginning

With the trial of Axis network cameras successfully concluded within the organization, the full rollout of over two hundred AXIS 2100 Network Cameras is now well underway.  Delivering high-quality images with the real opportunity of providing detailed photographic evidence of any criminal activity, the bank have been more than pleased with the speed at which the cameras have been installed.

“The speed in which we were able to install the new Axis network cameras was highly impressive.  The cameras consistently provide high-quality digital images with the level of detail that is necessary for good recognition.  We are extremely pleased with the results.  And, with the next phase of the project now focused towards transmitting images from our existing analog cameras over the network using AXIS 2400 Video Servers, this is really just the start of our migration strategy from CCTV to IP-Surveillance technology” commented Mr. Kleiber.

Share with LinkedIn Share with Twitter Share with Facebook Share with Facebook
Download PDF version Download PDF version

In case you missed it

Which Security Technologies Are Becoming Outdated Or Obsolete?
Which Security Technologies Are Becoming Outdated Or Obsolete?

When technology performs a required task effectively, there is little reason to upgrade to the ‘next big thing’. In this regard, the physical security market is notoriously slow to change. Much of yesterday’s most robust and dependable equipment is still in place at thousands of customer sites, still performing as well as the day it was installed. However, there comes a point when any technology becomes outdated. We asked this week’s Expert Panel Roundtable: Which security technologies are becoming outdated or obsolete?

Physical Security And The Cloud: Why One Can’t Work Without The Other
Physical Security And The Cloud: Why One Can’t Work Without The Other

Human beings have a long-standing relationship with privacy and security. For centuries, we’ve locked our doors, held close our most precious possessions, and been wary of the threats posed by thieves. As time has gone on, our relationship with security has become more complicated as we’ve now got much more to be protective of. As technological advancements in security have got smarter and stronger, so have those looking to compromise it. Cybersecurity Cybersecurity, however, is still incredibly new to humans when we look at the long relationship that we have with security in general. As much as we understand the basics, such as keeping our passwords secure and storing data in safe places, our understanding of cybersecurity as a whole is complicated and so is our understanding of the threats that it protects against. However, the relationship between physical security and cybersecurity is often interlinked. Business leaders may find themselves weighing up the different risks to the physical security of their business. As a result, they implement CCTV into the office space, and alarms are placed on doors to help repel intruders. Importance of cybersecurity But what happens when the data that is collected from such security devices is also at risk of being stolen, and you don’t have to break through the front door of an office to get it? The answer is that your physical security can lose its power to keep your business safe if your cybersecurity is weak. As a result, cybersecurity is incredibly important to empower your physical security. We’ve seen the risks posed by cybersecurity hacks in recent news. Video security company Verkada recently suffered a security breach as malicious attackers obtained access to the contents of many of its live camera feeds, and a recent report by the UK government says two in five UK firms experienced cyberattacks in 2020. Cloud computing – The solution Cloud stores information in data centres located anywhere in the world, and is maintained by a third party Cloud computing offers a solution. The cloud stores your information in data centres located anywhere in the world and is maintained by a third party, such as Claranet. As the data sits on hosted servers, it’s easily accessible while not being at risk of being stolen through your physical device. Here’s why cloud computing can help to ensure that your physical security and the data it holds aren’t compromised. Cloud anxiety It’s completely normal to speculate whether your data is safe when it’s stored within a cloud infrastructure. As we are effectively outsourcing our security by storing our important files on servers we have no control over - and, in some cases, limited understanding of - it’s natural to worry about how vulnerable this is to cyber-attacks. The reality is, the data that you save on the cloud is likely to be a lot safer than that which you store on your device. Cyber hackers can try and trick you into clicking on links that deploy malware or pose as a help desk trying to fix your machine. As a result, they can access your device and if this is where you’re storing important security data, then it is vulnerable. Cloud service providers Cloud service providers offer security that is a lot stronger than the software in the personal computer Cloud service providers offer security that is a lot stronger than the software that is likely in place on your personal computer. Hyperscalers such as Microsoft and Amazon Web Service (AWS) are able to hire countless more security experts than any individual company - save the corporate behemoth - could afford. These major platform owners have culpability for thousands of customers on their cloud and are constantly working to enhance the security of their platforms. The security provided by cloud service providers such as Claranet is an extension of these capabilities. Cloud resistance Cloud servers are located in remote locations that workers don’t have access to. They are also encrypted, which is the process of converting information or data into code to prevent unauthorized access. Additionally, cloud infrastructure providers like ourselves look to regularly update your security to protect against viruses and malware, leaving you free to get on with your work without any niggling worries about your data being at risk from hackers. Data centres Cloud providers provide sophisticated security measures and solutions in the form of firewalls and AI Additionally, cloud providers are also able to provide sophisticated security measures and solutions in the form of firewalls and artificial intelligence, as well as data redundancy, where the same piece of data is held within several separate data centres. This is effectively super-strong backup and recovery, meaning that if a server goes down, you can access your files from a backup server. Empowering physical security with cybersecurity By storing the data gathered by your physical security in the cloud, you're not just significantly reducing the risk of cyber-attacks, but also protecting it from physical threats such as damage in the event of a fire or flood. Rather than viewing your physical and cybersecurity as two different entities, treat them as part of one system: if one is compromised, the other is also at risk. They should work in tandem to keep your whole organization secure.

Hybrid Working And The Threat Of Desk Data
Hybrid Working And The Threat Of Desk Data

The transition to remote working has been a revelation for many traditional office staff, yet concerns over data security risks are rising. Mark Harper of HSM explains why businesses and their remote workers must remain vigilant when it comes to physical document security in homes. Pre-pandemic, home offices were often that neglected room in people’s homes. But now things are different. After the initial lockdown in 2020, 46.6% of UK workers did some work at home with 86% of those doing so because of the pandemic. Semi-Permanent workspaces Since then, many have found that over time, those semi-permanent workspaces have become slightly more permanent – with official hybrid working coming into effect for an assortment of businesses and their teams. The adoption of hybrid working can in fact be seen as one of the few positives to come from the pandemic, with less travel, more freedom and higher productivity top of the benefits list for businesses and their employees. The handling of sensitive documents, is a growing concern for office managers But those welcomed benefits don’t tell the whole story. The transition to remote working has undoubtedly impacted workplace security, with various touch points at risk. The handling of sensitive documents for example, is a growing concern for office managers. In simpler times, sensitive data was more or less contained in an office space, but with millions of home setups to now think about, how can businesses and their office managers control the issue of desk data? Physical document security As of January 2021, it’s said that one in three UK workers are based exclusively at home. That’s millions of individuals from a variety of sectors, all of which must continue in their efforts to remain data secure. With that, reports of cyber security fears are consistently making the news but that shouldn’t be the sole focus. There is also the underlying, but growing, issue of physical document security. The move to remote working hasn’t removed these physical forms of data – think hard drives, USBs and paper based documentation. A recent surge in demand for home printers for example, only exemplifies the use of physical documents and the potential security issues home offices are facing. Adding to that, research conducted in 2020 found that two out of three employees who printed documents at home admitted to binning those documents both in and outside of their house without shredding them. Data security concern Without the right equipment, policies and guidance, businesses are sure to be at risk Those findings present a huge data security concern, one that must be fixed immediately. The Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) has since released guidance for those working from their bedrooms and dining tables. Designed to help overcome these challenges, the ‘security checklists’ and ‘top tips’ should be the first port of call for many. Yet throughout, the ICO make reference to ‘following your organization’s policies and guidance’ – highlighting that the onus isn’t solely on the individuals working from their makeshift offices. Office managers have a monumental task on their hands to ensure teams are well equipped within their home setups. Without the right equipment, policies and guidance, businesses are sure to be at risk. But it would be wrong to insinuate that unsecure desk data has only now become an issue for organizations. Modern office spaces Keeping clear desks has long been a battle for many office managers. In fact, clear desk policies are practiced in most modern office spaces, with it recognized as a key preventative to personal information being wrongly accessed and so falling foul of GDPR legislation. Throwing sensitive documents in the bin was never an option pre-pandemic However, the unsupervised aspect of home working has led to a potentially more lax approach to these policies, or in some cases, they can’t be followed at all. For those taking a more laid back approach, organization leaders must remind staff of their data security responsibilities and why clear desk policies have previously proven effective. Ultimately, throwing sensitive documents in the bin was never an option pre-pandemic and this must be carried through to home workspaces now. Securely destroy documents There are also concerns over the equipment people have access to at home. For example, without a reliable home shredding solution, data security suddenly becomes a tougher task. To add to that, several recommendations state that employees working from home should avoid throwing documents away by instead transporting them to the office for shredding once lockdown rules ease. While this is an option, it does pose further issues, with document security at risk of accidental loss or even theft throughout the transportation period, not to mention the time spent in storage. The best and most effective way to securely destroy documents is at the source, especially in environments where higher levels of personal data is regularly handled. Correct shredding equipment The recent findings on home office behavior represent a true security risk Only when home workers implement their own clear desk policies alongside the correct shredding equipment (at the correct security level), can both home office spaces and regular offices become data secure. Realistically, these solutions should, like the common home printer, become a staple in home office spaces moving forward. The likelihood is that many UK workers will remain in their home offices for the foreseeable future, only to emerge as hybrid workers post-pandemic. And while the current working environment is more ideal for some than others, the recent findings on home office behavior represent a true security risk to organizations. With this in mind, it’s now more key than ever for business leaders, their office managers and homeworkers to all step up and get a handle on home data security policies (as well as maintaining their standards back at the office) – starting with the implementation of clear desk policies. After all, a clear desk equals a clear mind.