Download PDF version Contact company

In this article, Carlos Alonso, Director - Intrusion Detection Systems, Bosch, focuses on the two sets of guidelines that exist for the most popular detectors on the security market: EN50131-2-2 for passive infrared detectors, and EN50131-2-4 that relates to a combination of passive infrared and microwave detectors. The aim is to outline the standards that all manufacturers must adhere to

New European standards for electronic intrusion detection improve product quality

when developing these products.

A new single set of European standards for electronic intrusion detection systems was introduced several years ago, aimed at unifying and improving existing national standards. The result of this initiative is a set of regulations that manufacturers, distributors, installers and end-users must all follow. Moreover, countries without clear guidelines or with no guidelines at all will be able to benefit from a clear set of European standards outlining specification levels and requirements for security products. The standards will also enable end users to compare similar products, services and systems. 

For several years, the market has benefitted from a set of European guidelines (EN50131) relating to electronic intrusion detection systems. These guidelines document the standards that devices must fulfill in order to achieve specific security grades (numbered from Grade 1 to 4). The grades relate to security requirements that must be met by the different systems in order to combat various risks, as well as to ensure environmental protection. They range from low-risk (Grade 1), through low-to-medium risk (Grade 2), medium-to-high risk (Grade 3), to high-risk (Grade 4). There are also four equipment application grades (from indoor to outdoor use).

The new EN guidelines serve to regulate electronic intrusion detection devices - EN50131-2-2 and EN50131-2-4 relate to speifically to passive infrared detecteds and passive microwave infrared detectors

View larger image 

 1.0 - New EN guidelines for electronic intrusion detection

Currently, guidelines exist for intrusion systems, power supplies, warning devices and wireless elements, as well as for general alarm system requirements. All of these are covered by EN50131.

Specifications for Infrared or Dual Detectors


What do the standards say?

The standards themselves raise some important issues that are worth exploring as they help to explain the differences between the requirements for each detector grade.

Speed and positioning requirements during the general walk test

The test includes a series of criteria that must be met, taking into account the speed and position of the object. Grades 2 and 3 are highlighted specifically. The table here shows a series of intrusion detection situations where speed and position are taken into account. Table 1.1 shows that there is a series of priority requirements for detectors to comply with Grade 3.

Table displaying test of intrusion detection situations involving the speed and position of the detector

View larger image 

1.1 - Intrusion detection situations involving the speed and position of the detector

Immunity issues

Section 4.4 of the standard is an important section dealing with intrinsic immunity of individual detector technologies to external influences - specifically the technology's resistance to false alarms. Subsequent sections of the same document refer to tests and specific technical characteristics, which include the following:

♦ Immunity to air currents - An air current blowing in front of the detector must not cause the infrared component to generate any form of intrusion signal or message.

♦ Immunity to radiation visible to the infrared sensor from a source near to it - Radiation that is visible to the infrared sensor from a nearby light source such as a car headlamp must not cause the infrared component to generate any form of intrusion signal or message.

♦ Security against tampering - Table 1.2 shows the tamper-protection specifications for each detector grade.


Standardized test subject

Table showing tamper protection

View larger image

1.2 - Tamper protection specifications for each grade 


The standards also specify a test target (simulating a human being in a real intrusion situation). The height for this target must be between 160 cm and 185 cm, and it must weigh 70 kg (+ 10 kg). The target must wear tight-fitting clothing that emits heat over more than 80% of its surface area at wavelengths between 8 µm and 14 µm. No metallic objects may be worn or carried. The average temperature difference between the walk test target and the background must be measured. The temperature must be measured on areas of the test target's body on the surface, and the background temperature must be measured close to each simultaneously measured area. The areas are: 1) head, 2) chest, 3) back of hand, 4) knee and 5) feet. This demonstrates the importance of the standards in ensuring successful intrusion detection.

Table showing electrical requirements for Grade 2 and Grade 3 sensors

View larger image

1.3 - Electrical requirements for Grade 2 and Grade 3 sensors 

When in the disarmed mode, the detector must be able to generate an anti-masking signal within 180 seconds of the introduction of material being used to mask activity in its field of view. Signals or messages must constantly be emitted until the situation is resolved. When the device is inactive, normal human movement of 1 m/s at a distance of more than 1 m should not cause an anti-masking signal or message to be generated.


With regard to the anti-masking feature referred to in table 1.2, section 4.5.5 of the standard indicates that it must be possible to identify if the function of the detector is being hindered by the application of masking material, and if the detection area and sensor have been covered while the sensor was in inactive (i.e. disarmed) mode - thereby preventing the detection of movement afterwards. This leads to the following requirements:

  • When in the disarmed mode, the detector must be able to generate an anti-masking signal within 180 seconds of the introduction of material being used to mask activity in its field of view.
  • Signals or messages must be emitted constantly until the situation is resolved.
  • When the device is inactive, normal human movement of 1 m/s at a distance of more than 1 m should not cause an anti-masking signal or message to be generated.

An example of how detections systems are integrated to achieve immunity levels resulting in exceptionally reliable detection

View larger image

Example of integration of detection system
to provide reliable detection

Anti-masking testing

The detector must always meet the required standards and must be in inactive mode for every test. Any changes in signal or message state must be monitored.

There are several anti-mask tests: some so-called spray tests are intended to cover the detector lens with an invisible spray material, whereas other anti mask tests are focused on solid material that covers the detector, e.g. a cardboard box.

To carry out the spray test, an aerosol dispenser must be used to spray the materials specified in the following table. Spraying must be intermittent and each spray must be no longer than two seconds. For the transparent varnish test, the material must be applied with one brush stroke. Following each application, the detector should be switched into active mode after 180 s and the basic detection test should be carried out. Applications of the material should be repeated until the detector stops responding or until the anti-masking signal is generated.

Table showing materials used for masking tests

View larger image

1.4 - Materials used for masking tests

The sheet material samples specified in table 1.4 are applied directly onto the entire front part of the detector. If necessary, they can be cut to fit the detector window. Next, the samples should be applied again across the front of the detector at a distance of 0 and 50 mm. Two tests must be carried out, one that takes one second to cover the detector lens/window and the other 10 seconds. Self-adhesive vinyl is applied directly to the front of the detector. As with the spray-on and brush-on materials, after applying each material, 180 seconds should be allowed to elapse to enable the system to settle down before switching to active mode and monitoring for anti-masking indication. All the material samples must be large enough to hinder detection.

Pass/fail criteria: within 180 seconds of the device being masked, a signal or message must be emitted to indicate an intrusion or fault and must continue to be generated for as long as the material is in place. Alternatively, both the microwave and PIR technologies must continue to operate normally.

If an individual test fails, it must be repeated twice more. Two passes out of the three tests constitutes a passed test.

The importance of independent testing


Recognising the importance of the new EN50131 standards to their sales in Europe, many manufacturers are making rather enthusiastic claims for their intruder alarm products based on self-evaluation. However, for the new EN50131 standards to gain credibility and become widely accepted throughout the industry, it is essential for products to be certified by independent laboratories and not by the manufacturers themselves. A self-declaration of compliance to EN50131-2-4, for example, provides absolutely no guarantee of product quality or product features.

As in other industries, a completely independent laboratory must carry out the certification process. This will ensure that the entire security industry, from the manufacturers, distributors, installers through to the end-users, can implicitly trust the quality and function of the standards. Independent certification will also give recognition to the work of system manufacturers' R&D departments as well as the combined efforts of national and European associations to promote the correct implementation of the guidelines. And most importantly, it will mean that the end-user can be confident of receiving a product that meets all the new standard's relevant requirements.

For this reason, many national laboratories - such as CNPP in France, VdS in Germany and ANPI in Belgium - have already initiated product testing based on the available EN standards and technical specifications.

As a member of the CENELEC committee developing the EN50131 standards, Bosch Security Systems has been a strong supporter of the standard as an important quality label on which installers, distributors and end users can rely. It is also one of the first companies to submit its intrusion alarm products for independent certification. The relevant certificates, issued by CMPP, are published on the Bosch website and the company is making test reports available to potential customers on request to provide a guarantee of product quality based not only on a self declaration but also rigorous testing by an independent organization.Carlos Alonso, Director - Intrusion Detection Systems, Bosch Security Systems


Carlos Alonso
Bosch Security Systems
Director - Intrusion Detection Systems

Download PDF version Download PDF version

In case you missed it

Access The Right Areas - Making A Smart Home Genius With Biometrics
Access The Right Areas - Making A Smart Home Genius With Biometrics

Household adoption of smart home systems currently sits at 12.1% and is set to grow to 21.4% by 2025, expanding the market from US$ 78.3 billion to US$ 135 billion, in the same period. Although closely linked to the growth of connectivity technologies, including 5G, tech-savvy consumers are also recognizing the benefits of next-generation security systems, to protect and secure their domestic lives. Biometric technologies are already commonplace in our smartphones, PCs and payment cards, enhancing security without compromising convenience. Consequently, manufacturers and developers are taking note of biometric solutions, as a way of leveling-up their smart home solutions. Biometrics offer enhanced security As with any home, security starts at the front door and the first opportunity for biometrics to make a smart home genius lies within the smart lock. Why? Relying on inconvenient unsecure PINs and codes takes the ‘smart’ out of smart locks. As the number of connected systems in our homes increase, we cannot expect consumers to create, remember and use an ever-expanding list of unique passwords and PINs. Indeed, 60% of consumers feel they have too many to remember and the number can be as high as 85 for all personal and private accounts. Biometric solutions strengthen home access control Biometric solutions have a real opportunity to strengthen the security and convenience of home access control Doing this risks consumers becoming apathetic with security, as 41% of consumers admit to re-using the same password or introducing simple minor variations, increasing the risk of hacks and breaches from weak or stolen passwords. Furthermore, continually updating and refreshing passwords, and PINs is unappealing and inconvenient. Consequently, biometric solutions have a real opportunity to strengthen the security and convenience of home access control. Positives of on-device biometric storage Biometric authentication, such as fingerprint recognition uses personally identifiable information, which is stored securely on-device. By using on-device biometric storage, manufacturers are supporting the 38% of consumers, who are worried about privacy and biometrics, and potentially winning over the 17% of people, who don’t use smart home devices for this very reason. Compared to conventional security, such as passwords, PINs or even keys, which can be spoofed, stolen, forgotten or lost, biometrics is difficult to hack and near impossible to spoof. Consequently, homes secured with biometric smart locks are made safer in a significantly more seamless and convenient way for the user. Biometric smart locks Physical access in our domestic lives doesn’t end at the front door with smart locks. Biometrics has endless opportunities to ease our daily lives, replacing passwords and PINs in all devices. Biometric smart locks provide personalized access control to sensitive and hazardous areas, such as medicine cabinets, kitchen drawers, safes, kitchen appliances and bike locks. They offer effective security with a touch or glance. Multi-tenanted sites, such as apartment blocks and student halls, can also become smarter and more secure. With hundreds of people occupying the same building, maintaining high levels of security is the responsibility for every individual occupant. Biometric smart locks limit entry to authorized tenants and eliminate the impact of lost or stolen keys, and passcodes. Furthermore, there’s no need for costly lock replacements and when people leave the building permanently, their data is easily removed from the device. Authorized building access Like biometric smart locks in general, the benefits extend beyond the front door Like biometric smart locks in general, the benefits extend beyond the front door, but also throughout the entire building, such as washing rooms, mail rooms, bike rooms and community spaces, such as gyms. Different people might have different levels of access to these areas, depending on their contracts, creating an access control headache. But, by having biometric smart locks, security teams can ensure that only authorized people have access to the right combination of rooms and areas. Convenience of biometric access cards Additionally, if building owners have options, the biometric sensors can be integrated into the doors themselves, thereby allowing users to touch the sensor, to unlock the door and enter. Furthermore, the latest technology allows biometric access cards to be used. This embeds the sensor into a contactless keycard, allowing the user to place their thumb on the sensor and tap the card to unlock the door. This may be preferable in circumstances where contactless keycards are already in use and can be upgraded. Smarter and seamless security In tandem with the growth of the smart home ecosystem, biometrics has real potential to enhance our daily lives, by delivering smarter, seamless and more convenient security. Significant innovation has made biometrics access control faster, more accurate and secure. Furthermore, today’s sensors are durable and energy efficient. With the capacity for over 10 million touches and ultra-low power consumption, smart home system developers no longer have to worry about added power demands. As consumers continue to invest in their homes and explore new ways to secure and access them, biometrics offers a golden opportunity for market players, to differentiate and make smart homes even smarter.

Quantum Focuses On Unstructured Data, Embraces Pivot3 Acquisition
Quantum Focuses On Unstructured Data, Embraces Pivot3 Acquisition

Video is an enormous wellspring of unstructured data in the enterprise environment. Finding new ways to use video data requires easy access for analysis. Gone are the days when video was recorded just to be played back later. New computer capabilities can analyze video to provide business intelligence and trends, all of which requires that a lot of unstructured data be captured, stored and kept immediately accessible. It's a driving force for companies specializing in video storage such as Quantum, which is focused on storing and managing unstructured data, including video, photos, music and sound. Managing various analytics “Unstructured data is driving the massive growth in storage today, and video surveillance fits right in there,” says Jamie Lerner, CEO and President, Quantum. As data multiplies in business, matters of storing and accessing the data take on a larger profile. Especially challenging is meeting the need to store and access expanding amounts of unstructured data, such as video. Video is also part of a changing end-to-end architecture in the enterpriseWhereas 10 years ago, video surveillance was all about recording and playback, now the emphasis is much more on an end-to-end approach. In addition to capturing and playing back video, systems have to manage various analytics, archival and data retention aspects as well as recording. Video is also part of a changing end-to-end architecture in the enterprise, including hybrid, cloud and on-premise storage. Video surveillance industry Historically, structured data, such as financial information, was stored to allow future analytics. The same trend extends to unstructured data, such as video analytics. Quantum has expanded its video storage capabilities with acquisition this year of the video surveillance business of Pivot3, provider of a hyperconverged system that provides recording, analysis and seamlessly archives data on a converged platform that is less expensive and easier to manage. In acquiring Pivot3, Quantum is refocusing the smaller company on the video surveillance industry. “We are now focused 100% on surveillance and having the highest quality while being very cost-effective,” says Lerner. “The industry is ready for an IT-forward solution that is totally focused on surveillance. You can’t make a platform all things to all people.” Traditional security customers There is overlap in large stadiums and theme parks, where Lerner sees even more opportunity to expand Pivot3 will also help to expand Quantum’s customer base. The larger company has a history of serving customers in entertainment, movies, television and sports production. The addition of Pivot3’s 500 new customers in large surveillance, transportation and critical infrastructure markets will expand the mix. There is overlap in large stadiums and theme parks, where Lerner sees even more opportunity to expand. Pivot3 also helps to bridge the gap between traditional security customers and the information technology (IT) department. “Pivot3 has a reputation as simple to use,” says Lerner. “My belief is that physical security can run separately [from IT] until you reach a certain size, then IT has to be involved. Pivot3 gives IT people in the security space a product that is well formed and fits into an IT strategy. They are not undertaking a piece of equipment that will be a burden.” Physical security presence Customers expect their infrastructure vendors to provide systems that allow them to “Set it and forget it,” says Lerner. It’s one of the big advantages of cloud computing and also central to Quantum’s approach with their traditional products. “At the end of the day, you want to run a hospital, for example, so you want your systems to be easy to use,” says Lerner. The Pivot3 acquisition will also allow Quantum to expand their physical security presence more broadly and globally. Previously, the geographic reach of Pivot3 was limited by the high cost of placing personnel in diverse locations. Under Quantum, which has been serving global companies for 40 years, the problem disappears. “Quantum has global support on all continents and in more countries,” says Lerner. “It’s a higher level of support, given size and legacy of our organization.”

Data Explosion: Futureproofing Your Video Surveillance Infrastructure
Data Explosion: Futureproofing Your Video Surveillance Infrastructure

Video surveillance systems are producing more unstructured data than ever before. A dramatic decrease in camera costs in recent years has led many businesses to invest in comprehensive surveillance coverage, with more cameras generating more data. Plus, advances in technology mean that the newest (8K) cameras are generating approximately 800% more data than their predecessors (standard definition). Traditional entry-level solutions like network video recorders (NVRs) simply aren’t built to handle massive amounts of data in an efficient, resilient and cost-effective manner. This has left many security pioneers grappling with a data storage conundrum. Should they continue adding more NVR boxes? Or is there another, better, route? Retaining video data In short, yes. To future proof their video surveillance infrastructure, an increasing number of businesses are adopting an end-to-end surveillance architecture with well-integrated, purpose-built platforms for handling video data through its lifecycle. This presents significant advantages in terms of security, compliance and scalability, as well as unlocking new possibilities for data enrichment. All of this with a lower total cost of ownership than traditional solutions. Security teams would typically delete recorded surveillance footage after a few days or weeks Previously, security teams would typically delete recorded surveillance footage after a few days or weeks. However, thanks to increasingly stringent legal and compliance demands, many are now required to retain video data for months or even years. There’s no doubt that this can potentially benefit investigations and increase prosecutions, but it also puts significant pressure on businesses’ storage infrastructure. Data lifecycle management This necessitates a more intelligent approach to data lifecycle management. Rather than simply storing video data in a single location until it’s wiped, an end-to-end video surveillance solution can intelligently migrate data to different storage platforms and media as it ages. So, how does this work? Video is recorded and analyzed on a combination of NVR, hyperconverged infrastructure (HCI) and application servers. Then, it’s moved to resilient file storage for a pre-determined period, where it can be immediately retrieved and accessed for review. Finally, based on policies set by heads of security, data is moved from file storage to highly secure, low-cost archive storage such as an object, tape or cloud. Data is moved from file storage to highly secure, low-cost archive storage Long-Term storage This process is known as tiering. It allows businesses to use reliable, inexpensive long-term storage for most of their data, whilst still enabling security pioneers to retrieve video data when the need arises, such as during a compliance audit, or to review footage following a security breach. In a nutshell, it offers them the best of both worlds. Scaling your video surveillance infrastructure can be a headache. Businesses that rely on NVRs – even high-end units with 64 or even 96 hard drives – are finding themselves running out of capacity increasingly quickly. In order to scale, security pioneers then have to procure new boxes. With NVRs, this inevitably involves a degree of guesswork. Should they go for the largest possible option, and risk over provisioning? Or perhaps a smaller option, and risk running out of capacity again? Common management console Security pioneers can easily add or remove storage capacity or compute resources – separately or together As businesses add new cameras or replace existing ones, many end up with inadequate surveillance infrastructure made up of multiple NVR boxes along with several application servers for running other surveillance functions such as access control, security photo databases, analytics, etc. This patchwork approach leaves security pioneers scrambling for capacity, maintaining various hardware footprints, repeating updates and checks across multiple systems, and taking up valuable time that could be better spent elsewhere. By contrast, flexible HCI surveillance platforms aggregate the storage and ecosystem applications to run on the same infrastructure and combine viewing under a common management console, avoiding ‘swivel chair’ management workflows. Plus, they offer seamless scalability. Security pioneers can easily add or remove storage capacity or compute resources – separately or together. Data storage solutions Over time, this ensures a lower total cost of ownership. First and foremost, it removes the risk of over provisioning and helps to control hardware sprawl. This in turn leads to hardware maintenance savings and lower power use. Many security pioneers are now looking beyond simple data storage solutions for their video surveillance footage. Meta tags can provide context around data, making it easier to find and access when needed Instead, they’re asking themselves how analyzing this data can enable their teams to work faster, more efficiently and productively. Implementing an end-to-end video surveillance architecture enables users to take advantage of AI and machine learning applications which can tag and enrich video surveillance data. These have several key benefits. Firstly, meta tags can provide context around data, making it easier to find and access when needed. Object storage platform For instance, if security teams are notified of a suspicious red truck, they can quickly find data with this tag, rather than manually searching through hours of data, which can feel like looking for a needle in a haystack. Plus, meta tags can be used to mark data for future analysis. This means that as algorithms are run over time, policies can be set to automatically store data in the right location. For example, if a video is determined to contain cars driving in and out of your premises, it would be moved to long-term archiving such as an object storage platform for compliance purposes. If, on the other hand, it contained 24 hours of an empty parking lot, it could be wiped. These same meta tags may be used to eventually expire the compliance data in the archive after it is no longer needed based on policy. Video surveillance architecture Continuing to rely on traditional systems like NVRs will fast become unsustainable for businesses Even if your organization isn’t using machine learning or artificial intelligence-powered applications to enhance your data today, it probably will be one, three, or even five years down the line. Implementing a flexible end-to-end video surveillance solution prepares you for this possibility. With new advances in technology, the quantity of data captured by video surveillance systems will continue rising throughout the coming decade. As such, continuing to rely on traditional systems like NVRs will fast become unsustainable for businesses. Looking forward, when moving to an end-to-end video surveillance architecture, security pioneers should make sure to evaluate options from different vendors. For true futureproofing, it’s a good idea to opt for a flexible, modular solution, which allow different elements to be upgraded to more advanced technologies when they become available.